PLAYCALLER
MLB · First Basemen · 2026

Best Fantasy MLB First Basemen to Start in 2026

Live rankings based on recent fantasy performance and injury status. Updated daily. Click any player for a full start/sit analysis.

Last updated: November 3, 2026

Top 3 First Basemen Right Now

#1 🔥
BAL
17
avg fantasy pts (recent)
#2
STL
14.9
avg fantasy pts (recent)
#3
PHI
14.2
avg fantasy pts (recent)

Full First Basemen Rankings

# Player Avg Pts Tier Analysis
1 Pete Alonso
BAL
17 FLEX Analysis →
2 Alec Burleson
STL
14.9 FLEX Analysis →
3 Bryce Harper
PHI
14.2 FLEX Analysis →
4 Kyle Stowers
MIA
13.4 FLEX Analysis →
5 Matt Olson
ATL
13.1 FLEX Analysis →
6 Rafael Devers⚠ Injury
SF
12.4 ? Analysis →
7 Nick Kurtz⚠ Injury
OAK
12.2 ? Analysis →
8 TJ Rumfield
COL
11.8 SIT Analysis →
9 Jake Bauers
Milwaukee Brewers
11.7 SIT Analysis →
10 Willson Contreras
BOS
11.4 SIT Analysis →
11 Nathaniel Lowe
Cleveland Guardians
10.8 SIT Analysis →
12 Mark Vientos
NYM
10.7 SIT Analysis →
13 Munetaka Murakami
CWS
10.5 SIT Analysis →
14 Royce Lewis
MIN
10.2 SIT Analysis →
15 Ty France
San Diego Padres
9.9 SIT Analysis →
16 Michael Busch
CHC
9.4 SIT Analysis →
17 Sal Stewart
CIN
9.2 SIT Analysis →
18 Andrew Vaughn
MIL
8.4 SIT Analysis →
19 Jake Burger
TEX
8.3 SIT Analysis →
20 Vinnie Pasquantino
KC
8.2 SIT Analysis →
21 Josh Naylor⚠ Injury
SEA
8.1 ? Analysis →
22 Kyle Manzardo
CLE
8 SIT Analysis →
23 Spencer Horwitz
PIT
7.8 SIT Analysis →
24 Jared Young⚠ Injury
NYM
7.7 ? Analysis →
25 Freddie Freeman
LAD
7.7 SIT Analysis →
26 Spencer Torkelson
DET
7.7 SIT Analysis →
27 Dominic Smith
Atlanta Braves
7.4 SIT Analysis →
28 Spencer Steer⚠ Injury
CIN
7.2 ? Analysis →
29 Tim Tawa
ARI
7.1 SIT Analysis →
30 Gavin Sheets
SD
7 SIT Analysis →
31 Nolan Schanuel
LAA
7 SIT Analysis →
32 Paul Goldschmidt
New York Yankees
6.7 SIT Analysis →
33 Christian Walker
HOU
6.6 SIT Analysis →
34 Andrés Chaparro
WSH
6.6 SIT Analysis →
35 Rhys Hoskins
Cleveland Guardians
6.3 SIT Analysis →
36 Jonathan Aranda
TB
6 SIT Analysis →
37 Vaughn Grissom
LAA
5.7 SIT Analysis →
38 Rowdy Tellez
Atlanta Braves
4.1 SIT Analysis →
39 Deyvison De Los Santos
MIA
4 SIT Analysis →
40 Christopher Morel
NYM
3.8 SIT Analysis →

Get a roster-specific recommendation

These rankings are position-wide. PlayCaller's AI agent knows your team, your league scoring, and your opponents — and gives you a decision tailored to your roster every day.

Try Free for 7 Days →

Frequently Asked Questions

Who should I start at first basemen in fantasy this week?
Top first basemen to start: Pete Alonso (17 avg pts), Alec Burleson (14.9 avg pts), Bryce Harper (14.2 avg pts). Rankings update daily based on recent performance and injury reports.
What are the best MLB first basemen to pick up on waivers?
Check the full rankings table above for first basemen with high recent averages who may be available in your league. PlayCaller generates roster-specific waiver recommendations when you connect your Sleeper, ESPN, or Yahoo league.
How do I know which first basemen to start tonight?
Use the start/sit tier labels above — START means a strong play, FLEX means a borderline play, SIT means avoid if possible. For a personalized recommendation based on your specific roster and league settings, connect your league to PlayCaller's AI agent.

Other MLB positions

MLB Starting PitchersMLB Relief PitchersMLB ClosersMLB Catchers